I've attempted setting up Email forwarding multiple times, for multiple domains, with very little success.
I clicked the second radio button, filled in '*' for catch all, and the target Email and submitted the form. I got no error (but no confirmation either) and the information persisted on the form. However, revisiting the page shows that no information was actually recorded on the server, as it is all gone.
What's up with that? I really would like to get my Emails up and running...